[VS-series] ใ€Œใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹ใ€ vs ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€ vs ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€

ใ€Œใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹ใ€, ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€, andใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€. These three verbs are called ใ€ŒๆŽˆๅ—ๅ‹•่ฉžใ€(“giving and receiving verbs”) and are used when exchanging things with someone.
The verbs used differ depending on which point of view you are in: the giver or the receiver. Since it is rare for a language to have three different terms, it is said to be one of the most difficult verbs for Japanese learners to understand. Let’s take a look at the meaning of each and the concepts of ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€ (โ€œinside” and “outsideโ€).

Table of Contents

ย 

The concept of ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€

The concept of ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€ is important in understanding the verbs we learn here.

ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€directly translates to “inside” or “home” in English and refers to people who are (perceived as) on your side from the speaker’s point of view, such as friends or family.ใ€Œใใจใ€ refers to the rest of the people. The scope of ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€ depends on the context of the conversation. *When you read it the first time, you donโ€™t have to try to understand it fully. Read the meaning of each verb below, and then look back here again.

For example, if you consider yourself as ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ you can consider your mother as ใ€Œใใจใ€.

ๆฏใŒ้‡Ž่œใ‚’้€ใฃใฆใใ‚ŒใŸใ€‚
โ€œMy mother sent me vegetables.โ€

For example, if you consider your family, including your mother, to be ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ would be ใ€Œใใจใ€.

ใ€Œใ†ใกใฎๆฏใŒไผš็คพใฎๅŒๅƒšใซใŠ่“ๅญใ‚’่ดˆใฃใฆใ‚ใ’ใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œMy mother gave a sweet gift to my colleagues at work.โ€

Your colleagues can be also regarded as ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€. In this example, the general manager of another company is recognized as ใ€Œใใจใ€.

ใ€Œใ†ใกใฎไผš็คพใ‹ใ‚‰ใ€ๅ–ๅผ•ๅ…ˆใฎไผš็คพใฎ้ƒจ้•ทใซ้€€่ท็ฅใ„ใ‚’่ดˆใฃใฆใ‚ใ’ใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œOur company sent a retirement gift to the general manager of one of our clients’ companies.โ€

ใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹

AใŒBใซ๏ฝž(ใ—ใฆ)ใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹
โ€œA (the speaker) give/do something for B (someone)โ€
*ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ใŒใ€Œใใจใ€ใซ๏ฝž(ใ—ใฆ)ใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹
honorific: (ใ€œใ—ใฆ)ใ•ใ—ใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹

It means that the speaker gives or does something for the other person. Basically, the subject comes to the speaker, the speaker’s family, or people on the same team who fit intoใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ for the speaker.

ใ€Œใ“ใฎใ‚ทใƒฃใƒ„ใ‚’้–“้•ใˆใฆ2ใคๆณจๆ–‡ใ—ใกใ‚ƒใฃใŸใ‹ใ‚‰ใ€1ใคใฏๅฆนใซใ‚ใ’ใ‚ˆใ†ใ€‚ใ€
โ€œI ordered two of these shirts by mistake, so I’ll give one to my sister.โ€
*ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€: ็ง (I), ใ€Œใใจใ€: ๅฆน (younger sister)

ใ€Œ็งใฎใŠใ˜ใ„ใกใ‚ƒใ‚“ใŒ็งใฎๅฝผๆฐใซๅคใ„ๆœฌใ‚’ใ‚ใ’ใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œMy grandpa gave my boyfriend some old books.โ€
*ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€: ็งใฎใŠใ˜ใ„ใกใ‚ƒใ‚“ (my grandpa), ใ€Œใใจใ€: ็งใฎๅฝผๆฐ (my boyfriend)

ใใ‚Œใ‚‹

BใŒAใซ๏ฝž(ใ—ใฆ)ใใ‚Œใ‚‹
โ€œB (someone) give/do something for A (the speaker)โ€
*ใ€Œใใจใ€ใŒใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ใซ๏ฝž(ใ—ใฆ)ใใ‚Œใ‚‹
honorific: (ใ€œใ—ใฆ)ใใ ใ•ใ‚‹

It implies that the other person has given or done something for the speaker, and the speaker is grateful.

ใ€Œใ“ใฎใƒฌใ‚นใƒˆใƒฉใƒณใงใฏใ„ใคใ‚‚ๅญไพ›ใŸใกใซใŠ่“ๅญใ‚’ใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€‚ใ€
โ€œThis restaurant always gives my kids some snacks.โ€
*ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€: ๅญไพ›ใŸใก (my kids), ใ€Œใใจใ€: ใ“ใฎใƒฌใ‚นใƒˆใƒฉใƒณ (this restaurant)

Basically, it is a verb used to express gratitude for something the other person has voluntarily done for the speaker.
However, we often use ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€ when we want to say, “someone did such a great job (beyond our expectations),” even if the act was done because we asked them to do so.

ใ€Œ็งใŸใกใฎๆ—…่กŒไธญใ€ๅ‹้”ใŒใ†ใกใฎ็Šฌใฎไธ–่ฉฑใ‚’ใ—ใฆใใ‚ŒใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œDuring our trip, my friend took care of my dog.โ€

*In this case, the friend did not take care of the speaker’s pet voluntarily, but the speaker probably asked his friend to do so. The speaker uses this verb because he appreciates that his friend did a better job of taking care of the pet than he asked (or expected).

ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†

AใŒ(/ใฏ)Bใซ๏ฝž(ใ—ใฆ)ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†
*When the subject is “I” or “we”, we tend to use ใ€Œใฏใ€ as a particle.
โ€œA (the speaker) request/ask B (someone) to give/do something and s/he actually doesโ€
*ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ใŒใ€Œใใจใ€ใซ๏ฝž(ใ—ใฆ)ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†
honorific: (ใ€œใ—ใฆ)ใ„ใŸใ ใ

It implies that the other gives or does something the speaker asks for, and the speaker is grateful.

ใ€ŒไปŠๆœ้ ญใŒ็—›ใ‹ใฃใŸใฎใงใ€ๅง‰ใซ้ ญ็—›่–ฌใ‚’ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ„ใพใ—ใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œI had a headache this morning, so I asked my sister to give me some headache pills (and she did).โ€
*ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€: ็ง (myself), ใ€Œใใจใ€: ๅง‰ (my older sister)

Even when the action is not based on a request, it is preferred to use ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€ to express respect or gratitude for an action done by someone of higher age or status. (For example, when an action is performed by a king, a president, or an older person who is highly respected.)

ใ€Œ็คพ้•ทใซใฏใ€ๅปŠไธ‹ใงไผšใ†ๅบฆใซๆš–ใ‹ใ„ใŠ่จ€่‘‰ใ‚’ใ‹ใ‘ใฆใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ„ใพใ—ใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œThe president gave me warm encouragement every time I met him in the hallway.โ€

In this case, the speaker did not request the president to say, โ€œPlease give me warm encouragement,โ€ but the president must have encouraged the speaker by his own will. He did not request it, but he used ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€ to express his gratitude that the president took the trouble to comprehend my mind and treated me so kindly.

* As mentioned, there are many exceptions. As long as you use ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€correctly for the subject, you use eitherใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€ and ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€. So, rather than which verb to use, pay attention to whether you are using the right subject that fits the ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€ concepts.

Connecting after other verbs

All of these verbs mean โ€œgiveโ€ or โ€œreceiveโ€ when used alone, but when connected after another verb withใ€Œใฆๅฝขใ€(Te-form), they become ่ฃœๅŠฉๅ‹•่ฉž (auxiliary verbs), meaning โ€œsomeone does something for someone else.โ€

AใŒBใซ๏ฝžใ—ใฆใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹: A does something for B
ใ€Œ(็งใŒ)ๅ‹้”ใซๆผซ็”ปใ‚’่ฒธใ—ใฆใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹ใ€‚ใ€
โ€œI lend a comic book to a friend.โ€

BใŒAใซ๏ฝžใ—ใฆใใ‚Œใ‚‹: B does something for A
ใ€Œๅ…ˆ่ผฉใŒ(็งใซ)ใ“ใฎใ‚ทใ‚นใƒ†ใƒ ใฎไฝฟใ„ๆ–นใ‚’ๆ•™ใˆใฆใใ‚ŒใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œA senior colleague showed me how to use this system.โ€

AใŒBใซ๏ฝžใ—ใฆใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†: A asks /requests B to do something for A and B actually doesย (B does something for A on Aโ€™s request.)
ใ€ŒๆฏใŒใŠๅŒป่€…ใ•ใ‚“ใซๅคšใ‚ใซ่–ฌใ‚’ๅ‡บใ—ใฆใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใฃใŸใ€‚ใ€
โ€œMy mother asked the doctor to give her extra medicine, and he did.โ€

Which one should I use when talking about third parties?

These are verbs that can be used to refer to third parties that do not fall into either ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ and ใ€Œใใจใ€ without any problem. In such cases, check the following three items.

Who is the subject?
a giver belongs to ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€is ใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹; a giver belongs to ใ€Œใใจใ€ is ใใ‚Œใ‚‹; a receiver belongs to ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€ is ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†.

Whether the action was done upon request
If yes, itโ€™s ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†.

Whether the act was done by someone of higher status or age
If yes, itโ€™s ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†.

Example 1: When the status of the giver and receiver are different

When you see the news and want to say to your friend, “Ed Sheeran was awarded an MBE (Member of the Order of the British Empire)!” you can say as below.

ใƒใƒฃใƒผใƒซใ‚บ็š‡ๅคชๅญใŒใ‚จใƒ‰ใ‚ทใƒผใƒฉใƒณใซๅคง่‹ฑๅธๅ›ฝๅ‹ฒ็ซ ใ‚’ใ‚ใ’ใŸใฃใฆ๏ผ
โ€œPrince Charles gave Ed Sheeran the Member of the Order of the British Empire (MBE)!โ€
*There is a nuance of attention to Prince Charles, or the speaker is surprised by what Prince Charles did.

ใ‚จใƒ‰ใ‚ทใƒผใƒฉใƒณใŒๅคง่‹ฑๅธๅ›ฝๅ‹ฒ็ซ (MBE)ใ‚’ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใฃใŸใฃใฆ๏ผ
โ€œEd Sheeran received the Member of the Order of the British Empire (MBE)!โ€
*There’s a nuance of attention to Ed Sheeran, or the speaker is surprised by the fact that Ed Sheeran was chosen.

*In this case, Prince Charles is considered a person of higher rank than Ed Sheeran, so it is better to use ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€ than ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€.

Example 2: When the status of the giver and receiver are the same

If you want to tell your friends about the episode when Katy Perry and Taylor Swift made up like “Taylor baked cookies for Katie.โ€, you can say as below.

ใƒ†ใ‚คใƒฉใƒผใŒใ‚ฑใ‚คใƒ†ใ‚ฃใซใ‚ฏใƒƒใ‚ญใƒผใ‚’็„ผใ„ใฆใ‚ใ’ใŸใ‚“ใ ใฃใฆ๏ผ

“Taylor baked cookies for Katie.”
*There is a nuance of feeling that the speaker is just stating facts. Or like the speaker is talking about Taylor’s generosity from Taylor’s side (Taylor’s fan’s side).

ใƒ†ใ‚คใƒฉใƒผใŒใ‚ฑใ‚คใƒ†ใ‚ฃใซใ‚ฏใƒƒใ‚ญใƒผใ‚’็„ผใ„ใฆใใ‚ŒใŸใ‚“ใ ใฃใฆ๏ผ

“Taylor baked cookies for Katie.”
*There’s a nuance of being on Katy’s side [as a fan of Katy’s] and talking about Taylor’s kindness.

*In this case, Katie probably didn’t ask Taylor to bake cookies, and they are friends, so ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€ sounds more natural than ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€.

Situations

1- My son and I visited a friend’s house.

โ–ณๅ‹้”ใŒๆฏๅญใซใƒใƒงใ‚ณใƒฌใƒผใƒˆใ‚’ใ‚ใ’ใŸใ€‚
โ€œMy friend gave my son some chocolates.โ€

*Basically, the subject must be a person of ใ€Œใ†ใกใ€. When comparing a friend to a son, the friend is the person ofใ€Œใใจใ€, so when you would like to set the friend as the subject, you use ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€.
If you dare to use ใ€Œใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹ใ€ for this situation, it sounds like you blame your friend for giving chocolates to your son, who is not supposed to have them yet because he’s still one year old.

ๅ‹้”ใŒๆฏๅญใซใƒใƒงใ‚ณใƒฌใƒผใƒˆใ‚’ใใ‚ŒใŸใ€‚
โ€œMy friend gave my son some chocolates.โ€
*I am grateful for my friendโ€™s willingness to welcome my son with chocolates.

ๆฏๅญใŒๅ‹้”ใซใƒใƒงใ‚ณใƒฌใƒผใƒˆใ‚’ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใฃใŸใ€‚
โ€œMy son received chocolates from my friend.โ€
*I am grateful my friend gave my son chocolates because he wanted (or seemed to want) them.

2- Suddenly it rains unexpectedly.

๏ผˆ็งใŒ๏ผ‰ๅ‹้”ใซๅ‚˜ใ‚’่ฒธใ—ใฆใ‚ใ’ใŸใ€‚
โ€œI lent an umbrella to my friend.โ€
*I offered an umbrella to a friend who had not brought one.

ๅ‹้”ใŒ๏ผˆ็งใซ๏ผ‰ๅ‚˜ใ‚’่ฒธใ—ใฆใใ‚ŒใŸใ€‚
โ€œMy friend lent me an umbrella.โ€
*My friend was so kind as to lend me an umbrella, as I had not brought one with me.

๏ผˆ็งใฏ๏ผ‰ๅ‹้”ใซๅ‚˜ใ‚’่ฒธใ—ใฆใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใฃใŸใ€‚
โ€œI asked my friend to lend me an umbrella.โ€
*I had not brought an umbrella, so I asked a friend who had two umbrellas to lend me one.

Key points

ย ใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹ใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†
The subjectgivergiverreceiver
Upon requestyessometimes yesyes

Who is the subject:
If itโ€™s a giver, ใ€Œใ‚ใ’ใ‚‹ใ€ใ€Œใใ‚Œใ‚‹ใ€; receiver, ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€.

Whether the action was taken upon request:
If yes,ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€.

Whether the act was done by someone of higher status or age:
If yes, ใ€Œใ‚‚ใ‚‰ใ†ใ€.